[D컷] 아이돌 저작권 톱 ‘8’ Idol Copyrights top 8 - no.4
http://www.dispatch.co.kr/303459
아쉽게도 일본에만 나온 곡들이나
한국에서 냈는데도 어쩐 일인지;; 등록되지 않은 곡들 때문에 4위로 올라왔네요.
하루빨리 수정되길 바랍니다.
Yonghwa's no.4 on the list, but only 1 away from no.3, Miryo.
In fact, if Yonghwa's Japan releases (some that have been released in Korea too) were registered, it would make his position higher.
-
" ... if Yonghwa's Japan releases (some that have been released in Korea too) were registered, ... " I wonder if this occurrence is fnc usual practice for all their artistes or an oversight of fnc
-
it's sporadic. some are registered, some aren't... usually not if not released in Korea, but IMH WAS released in Korea.
-
Besides the fact that his Japanese songs aren't included (at least partially), I think another aspect is more important: in my opinion for a song the most important part is the music, than the lyrics and Yonghwa stands out at this point.
More than that, Yonghwa alone composed a lot of his (/Cnblue) songs (and also the lyrics), which is not the case for other artists. For me this aspect adds more value than the number of copyrighted songs i.e. I saw on this link (http://onehallyu.com/topic/41452-master-list-of-songwritercomposer-k-pop-idols/?p=2293749 - you can find Yonghwa under CNBLUE) if there is a song with 4 persons who wrote the lyrics, all of them will receive one copyright position instead of 1/4 of the respective song's copyrighted position. -
Hi, could you please refer to others in a different way, for example, "other artists," to be in line with our guidelines?
-
Ok, thanks - I tried to explain the reason, but you are right, is better to express like this...
-
To me it is not just about the ranking. FNC's incompetence in not registering Yong Hwa's songs is also robbing him of his copyright fees should those songs be used. This is his livelihood and such tardiness by FNC is inexcusable.
-
일본에만 나온 오리지널곡 수까지 합치면 몇곡일까영..Mr.kia, feeling, wake up, no more, have a good night, ring, monday, don't care, change, (truth, still, go your way, control, lonely night, angel, intro, radio, 내게로올까요)stay sober, 널좋좋, (in my head) 이정도인가요?
찾아보니 wave와 truth앨범은 국내 저작권도 등록되어있고요. 저작권협회 국외v로 클릭하면 JUNG YONG HWA로 된 곡에 제가 언급한 씨엔 이전 일본앨범 feeling등이 등록되어있긴하네요. In my head도 특이하게 한국어버전도 국외분류 되어있는 ㅡㅡ
지금은 71곡이라되어있고(며칠새 2곡 추가된?) 그럼 83곡인가.... -
Go your way는 또 정용화-국외로 되어있는..아주 중구난방
-
According with Wikipedia, the "Jung Yong-hwa writing and production credits" page has 82 entries, Korean, English and Japanese, therefore I think those who wrote the article wasn't at least tried to be informed properly (you should take into consideration more sources, and that is the "official" one!)...
-
It's likely such article or even Wikipedia may not have the most updated or complete info. I hope some fan(s) in SKorea will go into the official registration system there to check if YH songs releases have been registered. His company has been known to very tardy in handling YH matters previously (intentional or not ... I don't know) and it's no wonder his fans are concerned if his company registered all his composed songs. His fans do not want him to be "cheated" for his hard work especially in song-writing.
